pizza sauce recipe from fresh tomatoes

Pizza Sauce Recipe

By Swasthi on July 21, 2022, Comments, Jump to Recipe

This pizza sauce is incredibly easy to make, tastes delicious & is flavor-packed. Made with fresh tomatoes, garlic and herbs, this has the rich & deep flavors of a classic pizza sauce & is naturally gluten-free and vegan. The road to fresh, delicious, homemade pizza starts with a really great sauce. With the right ingredients and techniques you can create a dish that is both delicious and satisfying. Moreover, you can feel really good about making it yourself.


pizza sauce from fresh tomatoes

Homemade pizza is greater than the sum of its parts. It is so much more than just the crust, sauce, and toppings. Pizza lovers will agree that something quite amazing happens when these components come together in a perfectly baked pie, as the cheese mingles with the toppings and the sauce bakes into the crust.

When taking these things into consideration, pizza sauce is a key component that adds sweetness, acidity, moisture and flavor to your pizza and for that reason, it is important to use a pizza sauce that can deliver.

Why Homemade is the Best

Of course, there are so many options ranging from store-bought varieties to homemade versions. For those times when you are perhaps in a hurry and need convenience, a jar of store-bought pizza sauce may suit your needs.

The outcome will be dependent on the quality, thickness, and flavor of that sauce. Sometimes, those sauces may be good enough, but what they lack is freshness, taste & best flavors.

For that, a homemade sauce is the way to go. When time and ingredients allow, a homemade sauce can give you the best flavor, but beyond that, it is about designing a sauce that suits your taste.

How is it made

When making a fresh sauce, tomatoes can be prepared by removing the skins and seeds. This is a worthwhile step and is as simple as scoring the skins with a sharp knife and plunging them into a pot of boiling water for just a few seconds. A dip into an ice bath to cool them will help the skins slip off quite easily.

Next, cutting them in half will expose the seeds which are easily moved with a gentle squeeze to yield just the flesh which is what you are after. From there, you are all set to move forward with the process of preparing your sauce.

Alternately, a quicker fresh version is viable that involves pureeing fresh whole tomatoes. This method bypasses the peeling and seeding. By simply pureeing the tomatoes in a blender or food processor, you begin with a sauce that can be then cooked for a thicker consistency, depending on your desired outcome.

The benefit here is the fresh flavor of the tomatoes with greater ease and speed than the blanching method. This recipe uses this easier method.

pizza sauce recipe from fresh tomatoes

How to Make Pizza Sauce (stepwise photos)

1. Rinse and dice 500 grams tomatoes (1.1 pounds). Add them to a blender.

roma tomatoes for pizza sauce

2. Make a smooth puree.

pureed tomatoes in a blender

3. Heat a heavy bottom pan with 2 tablespoons of olive oil. When the oil becomes hot, stir in ¾ tablespoon finely chopped garlic.

sautéing garlic in oil

4. Fry the garlic for a minute or two until it turns fragrant. Stir in ½ to 1 teaspoon red chilli flakes (optional).

red chilli flakes in hot oil for pizza sauce

5. Lower the heat and let the chilli flakes fry in the oil for 30 seconds.

sautéing garlic chili in oil

6. Pour the tomato puree and stir.

pour tomato puree to pan

7. Quickly cover the pan as it begins to splash. Cook for about 15 minutes until the tomato puree turns slightly thick.

cooking tomatoes to make pizza sauce

8. Next add 1 teaspoon sugar & ½ to ¾ teaspoon salt. Sugar helps to balance the flavors.

sugar and salt being added to pizza sauce

9. Add ¼ to ½ teaspoon black pepper, ½ teaspoon oregano and ½ to ¾ teaspoon basil. You can add more herbs to your liking.

adding herbs to pizza sauce

10. Give a good mix and continue to simmer until pizza sauce cooks down to a thick yet spreading consistency. This takes another 5 minutes. Turn off the stove. Taste test and add more salt if required.

thickened tomato sauce in a pan

Cool it before spreading on your homemade pizza base.

pizza sauce

Cool this completely and store in an air tight clean dry glass jar. It keeps good for 2 weeks in the refrigerator & for 3 months in the freezer.

pizza sauce using fresh tomatoes

Ingredients & substitutes

Tomatoes

Having great ingredients is key so starting a pizza sauce with fresh, ripe tomatoes will always be optimal. If possible, it is best to work with tomatoes at the height of their season when they taste the best. The best tomatoes for making a pizza sauce are plum or roma tomatoes which have less water and therefore, yield a thicker sauce.

This does not mean that other tomatoes won’t work, however. Other garden varieties like beefsteak tomatoes can bring a great deal of flavor to the table, though you should be prepared to cook this type of sauce down a bit to get a sauce that is thick enough to stand up to your pizza.

One rule of thumb when creating your pizza sauce is that you should always use the best ingredients available to you. With that in mind, there are times when fresh tomatoes are not at their peak.

At times like that it may be in your best interest to use canned, whole tomatoes in place of fresh. Because canned tomatoes are picked and processed when tomatoes are ripe, you can count on consistency and flavor.

Seasoning
Perhaps the best part of making pizza sauce is the flexibility it allows when it comes to flavor. For those cooks who prefer a simple sauce, you can certainly create something very straightforward with the seasonings of your choice.

Others who are looking for something with a little more depth of flavor can reach for fresh herbs, garlic cloves, red chilli flakes & black pepper for some heat.

Fresh herbs provide a robust flavor when you have them on hand, though dried herbs certainly have their place in this process.

For those cooks who love garlic, nothing beats the punch of flavor it brings to your cooking, so use freshly chopped garlic. But garlic powder can offer a subtle nuance if used sparingly.

Finally, crushed black pepper & red chilli flakes can provide a desired level of heat to the pizza sauce. Even cayenne pepper can be used if you love the deeper color and depth of flavors it provides.

The point here is that homemade pizza sauce is customizable to your liking.

There are many ways to give your sauce a character. A good, full-bodied olive oil is best for maximum flavor that can really shine in your pizza sauce. However you may use any other for convenience.

Adding sugar will steer your sauce into a sweeter direction, while an unsweetened sauce will allow the acidity of the tomatoes to come through. You have total control over the taste and that is something you cannot get from a jar.

Ideas to use pizza sauce

If it just so happens that you find yourself with extra pizza sauce on your hands, there are a number of ways for you to utilize it. Here are a few suggestions:
Use it to create a sauce for a baked pasta dish.
Spread it over your roti/ chapati to make roti pizza.
Use it for a dipping sauce for cheese sticks, bread sticks, or garlic bread.
Freeze it to have on hand for the next time you are making pizza.

Faqs

How long does pizza sauce last in the fridge?

Pizza sauce keeps good in the fridge for 2 weeks if stored well in a clean dry glass jar . For better shelf life use dry spoons. It can be frozen for longer storage.

Is pizza sauce the same as pasta sauce?

No both are different. The consistency of pizza sauce is thicker than that of pasta sauce. However you may toss your pasta in pizza sauce and add some pasta cooked stock to help coat your pasta well with the sauce.

Can you freeze pizza sauce?

Yes you can freeze pizza sauce for 3 months. To retain the maximum flavors and taste, cool it right away after cooking and store it in a freezer safe glass containers and freeze it.

How to thicken pizza sauce?

Add nothing but simmer longer to evaporate most of the liquid in the tomatoes. This also develops a deeper & richer flavor & thickens your pizza sauce.

How to make pizza sauce without tomato paste?

You don’t need tomato paste to make pizza sauce, though it gives a much deeper flavor. Just puree fresh pulpy tomatoes and cook them down until the sauce becomes thick.

How to make no cook pizza sauce?

For those looking for a homemade sauce that does not require cooking, you can reach for canned tomato paste. This option will yield a thicker sauce that can be adjusted with the addition of a little water. From there, you can easily proceed with garlic, herbs, and seasonings according to taste.

What you will end up with is a pizza sauce with a more cooked flavor and a concentrated tomato flavor.

Related Recipes

Recipe Card

pizza sauce

Pizza Sauce Recipe

Make the easiest pizza sauce at home with fresh tomatoes and herbs. Packed with flavors and comes together under 20 minutes.
Pin Recipe Print Recipe

For best results follow the step-by-step photos above the recipe card

Prep Time2 minutes
Cook Time13 minutes
Total Time15 minutes
Servings1 cup
AuthorSwasthi

Ingredients (US cup = 240ml )

  • 500 grams tomatoes (ripe, 1.1 pounds, 2 cups tomato puree)
  • ½ to 1 teaspoon red chili flakes (adjust to taste)
  • ¾ tablespoon garlic fine chopped or minced
  • 2 tablespoons Olive oil
  • ⅓ to ½ teaspoon salt (adjust to taste)
  • 1 teaspoon sugar (to balance the flavors)
  • ½ teaspoon dried oregano
  • ½ to ¾ teaspoon dried basil (or 2 tbsps fine chopped fresh basil)
  • ¼ to ½ teaspoon crushed black pepper

Instructions

How to Make Pizza Sauce

  • Rinse tomatoes under running water and dice them. Puree them in a blender.
  • Heat oil in a pot and add finely chopped garlic. Saute for 1 to 2 minutes until garlic becomes aromatic.
  • Then add red chilli flakes if using and give a quick mix.
  • Pour the tomato puree and stir. Cover immediately and cook on a medium to low heat until the sauce thickens slightly. This takes about 15 mins.
  • Stir in between to prevent the tomatoes from burning. Be careful as the sauce splashes. You may turn down the heat and stir.
  • Then add salt, sugar, oregano, black pepper and basil. Mix and continue to cook for another 5 mins, until the sauce becomes thick. When it is done you will see traces of oil on the sides and top.
  • Turn off and add more salt if needed. Cool this completely and store in an air tight glass jar.
  • Pizza sauce keeps good in the refrigerator for 2 weeks and for 3 months when frozen.

Notes

  • I prefer to add the herbs after the sauce is half cooked. If you prefer to add in earlier you may add them along with the red chilli flakes.
  • Nutritional values are for the entire yield (1 cup)

Alternative quantities provided in the recipe card are for 1x only, original recipe.

For best results follow my detailed step-by-step photo instructions and tips above the recipe card.

Video

NUTRITION INFO (estimation only)

Nutrition Facts
Pizza Sauce Recipe
Amount Per Serving
Calories 367 Calories from Fat 261
% Daily Value*
Fat 29g45%
Saturated Fat 4g25%
Sodium 819mg36%
Potassium 1185mg34%
Carbohydrates 26g9%
Fiber 6g25%
Sugar 17g19%
Protein 5g10%
Vitamin A 4462IU89%
Vitamin C 70mg85%
Calcium 72mg7%
Iron 2mg11%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Tried this recipe?Mention @SwasthisRecipes or tag #swasthisrecipes!

© Swasthi’s Recipes

Pizza Sauce Recipe

About Swasthi

I’m Swasthi Shreekanth, the recipe developer, food photographer & food writer behind Swasthi’s Recipes. My aim is to help you cook great Indian food with my time-tested recipes. After 2 decades of experience in practical Indian cooking I started this blog to help people cook better & more often at home. Whether you are a novice or an experienced cook I am sure Swasthi’s Recipes will assist you to enhance your cooking skills.

Follow Swasthi’s Recipes

Recipe Rating




49 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

5 stars
absolutely awesome!

5 stars
I canned this recipe and it turned out great, thanks!

5 stars
This is delicious! I added your pizza sauce recipe to our home cookbook My husband really thought it tasty! We used paste tomatoes and herbs from our garden. Thank you.

5 stars
Forgot to add 5 stars!!

Really incredible pizza sauce! Delicious and easy. I used fresh beefsteak tomatoes and the only other changes were to reduce the garlic to 1/2 tablespoon and only used a pinch of red pepper flakes. Will definitely be making again. Thanks for this recipe.

5 stars
Oh wow! This pizza sauce beats any I have had at any pizza place! Thank you! Will being using this on a Detroit style pizza I’m making tonight. Phenomenal!

5 stars
Oh also, I used the blender method and it took quite some time (hours) to get thick enough due to my watery tomatoes but it eventually did, just as advertised 😊

5 stars
Found this recipe when I needed to use up 32 tomatoes from my garden, so easy and SO GOOD; got another big batch o’ tomatoes now so making again! Highly recommend

5 stars
Hi can you make the recipe of mozzarella cheese recipe pls the mozzarella cheese we get here is very bland it just gives strech but totally tasteless and flovourless can you show the recipe without renet pls

I’m making this right now, but it is very watery. I don’t see it thickening. I did the blender method, could I have blended too much?

5 stars
Hi swasthi I have a doubt I have brought yeast last year which is March 2020, 500 grams packet it’s expiry is 1 year which is April 2021 but now I have so much of it the problem is can I throw it or can I use it and can you say how store the yeast for long term pls.

5 stars
Hi can we remove the seeds of tomato because it makes sauce sour can we do it

Tried it number of times, it came out great every time!
Can you pls share recipe to make chicken shawarma roll at home.
Kolkatta Kathi rolls as well, my son would like to try making.

Can you cann this sauce?

5 stars
Hi Swasthi,

I tried this pizza sauce recipe and it turned out great. Thank you for sharing

5 stars
Hi can we use fresh sweet basil to this sauce,
If yes can say the quantity of fresh sweet basil leafs??
And can we add tomato ketchup to this recipe??

5 stars
I don’t have oregano ☹️☹️ what should I do can I add ajavaayan ke pathe which is used for cough and known as indian oregano what should I do ☹️☹️

5 stars
My pizza sauce came out very good but became very sour. Please suggest how to reduce that. Will it be good to use. Thank you

Thank you. As you said it balanced and went well on the pizza.

5 stars
hii

can you show me hot n sour soup recipe>>??

5 stars
happy to learn cooking, recipes with images it helps a lot.

Thank you

Hi swasthi
Cud u please share garlic sauce too

Thanks